Five Stories – Ellen Weinstein


Summary: Visit the Lower East Side of New York through the eyes of five children and their families who live in the same building over the course of a century. Meet Jenny Epstein in the 1910s, Anna Cozzi in the 1930s, José Marte in the 1960s, Maria Torres in the 1980s, and Wei Yei on the Lower East Side of today.

See how, as each child grows, they make an impact on the family that comes after them, from Jenny growing in to the young Anna Cozzi’s English teacher to Maria Torres running the comic store where Wei Yei shops. Five Stories is a cross section of American history that celebrates the many diverse cultures that make up our nation – from the food we eat to the ways we worship and the families we love.

(Summary from book flap – Image is mine – This book was given to me for free in exchange for an honest review)

My Review:  Five Stories explores the lives of five different families who have lived in the same apartment building on the Lower East Side of New York City over the course of a century. Each story is told from a child’s perspective as they discuss different aspects of their lives, histories, and culture. Right out of the gate, I was tickled by the titular pun –> a book called Five Stories tells five stories about a building that is five stories. My brain absolutely lit up at the play on words.

This book has a nostalgic feel that may appeal to fans of The Little House by Virginia Lee Burton who like to see historical progression within a story. I love the illustrations, which show the evolution of an apartment building and the surrounding neighborhood over time. With a turn of each colorful page, readers will watch as fashions change, businesses come and go, and transportation evolves in a bustling borough. There is plenty of detail to explore on every page and it was interesting to see how the illustrator chose to depict the flow of history through their artwork.

I adored the subtle connections that existed between each story, like how Jenny Epstein grew up to become Anna Cozzi’s teacher, or how Wei Ye purchased his comic books from a shop owned by a grown-up Maria Torres. While these little touches weren’t necessary for the story, it brought everything together quite nicely and showed how past generations have influenced and helped shape our own experiences.  

My favorite aspect of this book was its sensitive treatment of the immigrant experience as it explored each family’s reasons for moving to NYC. Many fled religious or political persecution or sought financial stability for their families.  I think it is important for children to understand why many people choose to immigrate and stories like this help to cultivate compassion for people from different backgrounds, rather than bigotry and fear.  I also loved the diverse ethnic representation within the stories, which allow the reader a glimpse into the cultures and traditions of each family.  
Overall, Five Stories is a charming children’s book that explores the history of a diverse neighborhood through the eyes of the children who lived there. It is recommended for readers 4-8 years old (or PreK to 3rd grade) but I think readers of all ages could learn a little something from this book.  
My Rating: 4.5 Stars

For the Sensitive Reader: All Clear



Source link